Apple’s shares were down just over $3 or 2.1% to $141.17 on Tuesday, while the Nasdaq only fell 0.6%. The stocks weakness was largely attributed to Apple analyst Ming-Chi Kuo of TF International Securities writing, “The total iPhone 14 Pro and 14 Pro Max shipments in the December quarter will be 15-20 million units less than expected. Significant downside risks to Apple & iPhone supply chain due to Zhengzhou iPhone plant labor protests.” Philip Elmer-DeWitt at Apple 3.0 has a synopsis of what Kuo wrote.
While this is only a sample size of one, the Apple store I visited this week had no iPhone 14 Pro models in stock. And when they do get them, it receives two shipments a day, they sell out very quickly.
Mike O’Rourke from JonesTrading (no relation) wrote in his daily note that Apple “only” being down 20% for the year vs. the S&P 500 falling 17% and the Nasdaq cratering 30% has done much better than other large cap tech companies. He noted that, “Thus far in 2022, Meta Platforms is down 67%, Tesla is down 48.6%, Nvidia is down 47%, AmazonAMZN
is down 44.6%, Google is down 34% and MicrosoftMSFT
is down 28.5%.”
While Apple’s stock may maintain its outperformance, if any concerns such as iPhone production being limited become more pronounced the shares could be exposed to performing worse than the overall markets.
Revenues and earnings could fall in fiscal 2023
Keep in mind that Apple saw its total revenue decline in fiscal 2016 by 8% and in fiscal 2019 by 2%. In his report detailing Apple’s September and fiscal year 2022 Toni Sacconaghi wrote, “we expect consensus revenues and EPS to fall for fiscal 2023.Apple did not provide guidance for December revenues, other than to say growth would be lower than September quarter levels (of 8%). Our take is that management does not have conviction that it can grow revenues in the December quarter – despite enjoying an extra week that should contribute an additional ~ 7% of revenues – in part because of uncertainty surrounding iPhone 14 and wearables, which it continues to believe is its most economically sensitive business.”
The company saw revenue growth explode in fiscal 2021 and is up 52% from fiscal 2019 to 2022. It would not be surprising to see revenue growth slow if not turn negative since so many users have bought recently available products.
Fiscal year revenues
2019: $260 billion
2020: $275 billion, up 5.5%
2021: $366 billion, up 33.3%
2022: $394 billion, up 7.8%
Low $383 billion, down 2.9%
Average $406 billion, up 3.0%
High $420 billion, up 6.5%
2024 estimates vs. 2023 average:
Low $406 billion, flat
Average $428 billion, up 5.4%
High $449 billion, up 10.6 %
EPS, not surprisingly, have a larger range of estimates since there are more variables, such as margins and expenses, that impact it.
Low $5.40, down 12%
Average $6.24, up 2%
High $6.87, up 12%
2024 estimates vs. 2023 average:
Low $6.01, down 4%
Average $6.81, up 9%
High $7.36, up 18%
Valuation remains elevated
While Apple’s stock valuations had lagged the overall markets a few years ago, due to its financial outperformance and it Services revenue growing faster than the hardware side of the business (along with much higher margins), its P/E ratio has increased substantially. However, if its growth profile remains under pressure, the premium valuation it has recently received could deteriorate.
Apple forward P/E
Toni Sacconaghi, Bernstein
Technically the shares have more downside risk than upside potential
Carter Braxton Worth is founder of Worth Charting and frequent CNBC guest. He follows the markets as a technician and was the Chief Market Technician at Oppenheimer, Sterne Agee & Leach and Cornerstone Macro for almost 20 years before recently founding his own firm. This chart is from November 9 when Apple’s stock closed at $135. Over the next three weeks the shares rallied to $151 but pulled back to $141 on Tuesday.
Worth believes that the shares are exposed to the downside as indicated by the stock not being able to break above its January 3 closing high of $182.01
Apple stock price
Carter Braxton Worth at Worth Charting
Apple’s shares have been volatile over the past 18 months, trading between $130 and $180. If they break below $130 the next level of support is $120, with downside from there to around $110.
Apple stock chart